He went forward with it anyway, but when his ships were decimated by a fleet of rogue synths, Starfleet gave up all rescue efforts. Desperate to advance his cause, Marcus roused the leader of the group, Khan Noonien Singh, and held the rest of Khan's people hostage while Khan himself was forced to develop advanced weapons for the Federation under the secretive Section 31. Spore drive ready for fleet-wide dissemination and implementation, including biological component is an instant winner in any conflict, not just cold war against splintered enemy. In the Kelvin timeline, though, the absence of Kirk's father sent him off on a very different path, one with much less conviction and certainty early on. 7v7: Prime Timeline Starfleet vs Kelvin Timeline Starfleet - Reddit Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. When evacuation efforts failed, Spock now an ambassador from his homeworld of Vulcan intervened in 2387 with his own attempt to halt the supernova through the use of red matter. Over 100 space rocks collected by meteorite hunter Geoffrey Notkin are up for action today, How California museum is protecting space shuttle Endeavour against earthquakes, Gorgeous photos show SpaceX's next Starship Super Heavy booster on the launch pad. Ex Astris Scientia - The Continuities of Star Trek trekmovie.com Nero is eventually defeated, and Spock's young and old take a moment to reflect on their coexistence. Jim Kirk grows up as a rebellious punk constantly trying to outrun his fathers long shadow. Co-writer for the 2009 Star Trek movie Roberto Orci backed this up in an interview when asked if the new timeline had wiped out the old one, answering, it continues. He wakes one of them up Khan Noonien Singh and forces him to build weapons that Earth could use to defend itself against alien threats. It works.September 15, 2017. One of his first acts is to destroy the U.S.S. They are very much unlike the "flippable muzzle" versions seen in the Kelvin timeline. Spurred on by Pike, Kirk joined Starfleet and eventually tricked his way onto the newly launched Enterpriseafter cadets in the Academy were called into service to help battle Nero. With Spock Prime's help including the introduction of transwarp beaming to the Kelvin timeline Kirk and Spock were able to make amends and defeat Nero before he could destroy Earth, cementing the dynamic of the Enterprise crew. According to the most successful, most tested scientific theory ever, quantum mechanics, it continues. In that same interview he also points to The Next Generation episode Parallels (where Worf slips from one reality to another after passing through a quantum fissure). Visit our corporate site. So how exactly did the Kelvin Timeline come about, and what's happened since? Aurora colors: What causes them and why do they vary? Prime canon and the Kelvin Timeline : r/startrek - Reddit RELATED: The Biggest Threat to Star Trek: Legacy Is Losing Terry Matalas. (The following has spoilers. Hes a soldier and he believes that he should be allowed to do what he does best. Can a creature that "loses indestructible until end of turn" gain indestructible later that turn. This all came to a rather disappointing stop, however, back in 2005 when the Star Trek: Enterprise went off the air, leaving a large void for the first time in years. With all of the action and excitement happening in the Prime Universe, here's why the Kelvin Timeline of J.J. Abrams' Star Trek movies is no longer relevant and or advantageous, and why Star Trek 4 should bring the movies' Starship Enterprise crew into the Prime Universe. The story of Star Trek's Kelvin timeline began in the Prime Star Trek universe in the 2380s, when it became clear that the Romulan sun presented a major danger not just to the Romulan Star Empire but to a whole quadrant of the galaxy. That's fairly solid. In fact, 2009 film writer and Discovery producer Kurtzman has explained the Prime and Kelvins similarities and improbable coincidences as the timestreams way of trying to mend itself a line that was at one point written for Prime Spock in the movie when he impossibly meets Kelvin Kirk in a cave. As the Romulan vessel attacked, First Officer George Kirk took command of the Kelvin after the death of his captain, and he sacrificed the ship to protect the escape shuttles fleeing the area,including the one carrying his wife and newborn son, James Kirk. The Kelvin timeline of Star Trek is fascinating for a number of reasons, including the fact that it didn't have to exist this way at all. As far as I'm aware it was implied that (1) was from the rebels database. The year 2233 is when the Kelvin timeline diverges from the prime timeline. However, in the Kelvin timeline, it is Admiral Alexander Marcus who wakes Khan from his slumber. That's two advancements in one. Serious, in-depth discussion about *Star Trek.*. The idea floated is that there is a most probable version of reality that happens more than others, despite minor differences. Although for TNG they had one thing about holograms on the holodecks not seen in discovery: They were solid. Yes. A short time later, Kirk was also marooned on Delta Vega by an irate Spock, who was acting captain of the Enterprise and had already discerned Nero was a time traveler. Interestingly, when interviewed about season 2, co-creator Alex Kurtzman addressed the idea of who might be on the Enterprise, stating I think there will be some surprises there. A few comments I read before Star Trek: Discovery premiered indicated it was part of the original timeline, but after seeing the show I'm not 100% sure: many of the consoles we see here are similar to those in the current films. And I mean it in the strategic sense, as they knew Kelvin was attacked by unknown species with a ship of unknown capabilities. Technically the Kelvin timeline and Prime timeline coexist and run concurrently together, so why not other variations? Kelvin, killing. Let's not ignore prime timeline problems to blindly accept these statements. Are you suggesting that the displays of TNG DS9 and VOY were all holographic as well? If that were true, it makes everything we know about Voyager's doctor and the issuea he had with mobility really weird. That bit of ugliness behind them, the Enterprise receives its five-year-mission. That's the Klingons. That's interesting, but that does not mesh with anything else in established prime canon. The Doctor was impressed that emitters were on every deck of the Prometheus. Some things are clear contradictions. So, at the end of the 24th century, the planet Romulus is destroyed. The sacrifice that leads to victory happens just as in the original, except in the Kelvin timeline its Kirk who gives his life to save his crew. As I mentioned before, series co-creators, like Alex Kurtzman, have been very good at talking around settings without being completely definite. Star Trek: Discovery kicks off in 2256, ten years before the events of Star Trek: The Original Series. Establishing what universes actually exist is probably the best place to start. Nero captured Spock's ship, the Jellyfish, and left the Vulcan stranded on the icy planet Delta Vega, with the intention of making Spock watch his own homeworld perish just as Nero had to watch Romulus fall. How did this hand from the 2008 WSOP eliminate Scott Montgomery? The destruction of Romulan, an event that the 2009 Star Trek states takes place ion the prime timeline, plays as major context to the events of 2020s Picard. Paramount wanted a prequel film, showing what led Captain James T. Kirk and the much loved, much memed, Spock to where audiences see them in The Original Series. However, the appearance of the Kelvin is not necessarily the problem. Star Trek's success dates back to the 1960s, when Gene Roddenberry's singular vision challenged societal norms by painting a . @starpilotsix, do you have any canon evidence that the Xindi war wasn't in the same timeline as TNG? This meant that the entire was subjected to genetic modification and had their appearances altered. Scan this QR code to download the app now. After the destruction of Vulcan, Starfleet is no longer the same utopian Starfleet audiences have grown to know and love (ignoring their problematic tendencies) from the previous iterations into the franchise. That's not to say they were not interesting or exciting, but there wasnt much canonically there to explore. I'm confused as hell after I saw the episode chronology recently posted on r/startrek. That might seem cut and dry if it wasnt for the fact that these tweets went out before the show aired, as fans reacted more to the look of the show than the content: Have faith; look past the surface, past the superficialities of aesthetics. In Kelvin, however, the Franklin is half-buried after crashing into the surface of the planet Altamid. Visit our corporate site. Between 2006 and 2019, CBS Television and Paramount owners Viacom were separate companies. But why is Pike older and on Earth instead of commanding the NCC-1701 in the year 2258, just one year after he would have temporarily commanded USS Discovery? But the best stories are going to explain it not write it off. That was before the Kelvin was destroyed. Remember that the Kelvin timeline has things happening about 7 years earlier: Kirk takes command of the Enterprise in 2258 (original timeline, 2265), so the first Kelvin timeline film happens two years after ST: Discovery. Why i suspect that Discovery was intended to be part of the Kelvin timeline is in details such as this: GamesRadar+ is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Kelvin vs Prime? : r/StarTrekDiscovery - Reddit The Star Trek universe encompasses over two dozen films and series spanning 57 years. Released: July 6, 2016 Rewards Experience Points: 9159 Expertise: 9550 Dilithium Ore: 480 You will receive the following reward: [Kelvin Timeline Bat'leth Mk XI] [Console - Tactical - Directed Energy Distribution Manifold Mk XI] [Console - Tactical - Prefire Chamber Mk XI] [Console - Tactical - Warhead Yield Chamber Mk XI] New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Apr 15, 2021 #1 Star Trek Universe TV Head Alex Kurtzman Says Line Between Movies And Television Is "Gone" He also talks about how TV showrunners are coordinating their Star Trek stories. Kirk et al save the day, of course. Kirk and the ships he encountered did not use them. It only takes a minute to sign up. The writers of 2009's Trek film could have simply said, "We're starting over, but the other films and shows are all still there for you to watch." The Enterprise tries to stop him and fails, though they do manage to rescue Spocks father, Sarek. The first installment of his superhero fiction book, TALES OF ADVENTURE & FANTASY, is available on Amazon in print and ebook! If you want to rewatch the new Star Trek movies, our Star Trek streaming guide will show you where to watch them all online. The alternate reality differed from the primary reality in a number of capacities, including the attack upon the USS Kelvin, the launch of the USS Enterprise in 2258, and the . In Into Darkness (2013), Alexander Marcus, leader of the secretive Section 31, finds the SS Botany Bay, stuffed to the rafters full of augmented humans in cryostasis. In the run-up to the 2009 film, IDW released a prequel comic series featuring many of The Next Generation characters. Enterprise is noteworthy but very conventional. Classic Star Trek Continuity Kelvin Timeline Discovery Continuity Continuity Workaround at EAS The live-action TV series and movies produced by Star Trek's copyright owners are canon by definition. What is the SFX process for phaser beam accuracy? In the Kelvin timeline, life unfolds in a way that's quite recognizable for longtime Star Trek fans but with many differences interspersed throughout the universe. Star Trek, Next Generation, Voyager, Deep Space Nine, and Enterprise, all take place there. Is Star Trek: Discovery set in the original or the Kelvin timeline The characters and situations in the movies were off-limits . Rather than simply trying to tell a prequel story or reboot the continuity entirely, writers Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman crafted a way to connect the film to what came before. Order of events between Prime and Kelvin timelines. He figures Kirk will kill, not capture, Khan, thus removing a threat and evidence of Marcus secret project. This version of James T. Kirk was a rebellious young man, joyriding in stolen cars as a teenager and getting into bar fights in his 20s. Anyone who did know about it would just assume it had passed by now. Unlike Prime Carol, who often felt suspicious toward Starfleet, the Kelvin Timeline's Carol Marcus actually joined the interstellar organization as a science officer and expert in advanced weaponry. Directed by J.J. Abrams and starring Chris Pine, Zachary Quinto, and Zoe Saldana, Star Trek introduced the world to new versions of classic characters like Kirk, Spock, and Uhura, and it took us back to their earlier days in Starfleet. So there's evidence it's not in the Kelvin timeline. But it's not a mystery to the Starfleet of the future. Archived post. The sudden destruction of Vulcan and the losses in the Federation fleet during the battle with Nero, coupled with the growing hostility of the Klingons, spurred certain factions within Starfleet to seek a more militaristic approach to dealing with the future of the galaxy. You know the one. Another possibility is that Discovery takes place mostly in the prime universe while "Despite Yourself" features a different mirror universe from what past series have shown -- the Terran Empire in this second mirror universe having acquired its USS Defiant from one of the countless other universes where things happened just a bit differently from the prime universe. Spock emerged in 2258 while the Romulans landed in 2233. Season 2 you say?!! What's the DC of a Devourer's "trap essence" attack? So I will call it "Discovery Universe", as it is a bubble of completely different latex Canon tells us Klingons acquired cloaking tech from Romulans. They wanted to retell a story that everyone knew and do it differently, all without breaking the well-respected canon that fans have grown so attached to. Let me first challenge by saying that if we favor a prime placement, we still need to resolve some problems. If DSC is set in the prime timeline, the Klingons should not have cranial ridges and use Bat'leth-like weapons. Scan this QR code to download the app now. It's even shown that Kelvin Timeline vessels can take more damage than Prime Timeline ships (most notably referenced by the Vengeance remaining structurally intact after that internal explosion of torpedoes). rev2023.7.24.43543. Until 2009, all canon Star Trek was set in the same timeline (although owing to time travel it was frequently subject to subtle changes). They look nothing like the uniforms seen the show, either in "the present" (2256) or in the flashback set in 2249 when Burnham met Georgiou. Alice is a Lord of the Rings enthusiast who grew up with Tolkien's tales. There's also evidence within the series itself. However, Star Trek Beyond, the last film of Abrams' trilogy, happens 3 years before Captain Kirk (takes command of the Starship Enterprise in the Prime timeline. This was a big deal remember. Simply saying it doesn't make it so. This is clearly a reference to Nero, the Romulan villain of the 2009 movie, who instigated the alternate timeline when he traveled back a hundred years and destroyed the U.S.S. The premise was that the Romulan Sun destabilized, and before Spock could save his alien cousins, the planet was destroyed. If Discovery does take place in the original timeline, then Lorca's schematic may be an unused early model or conceptual refit sketch. You dont end on a meeting TOS-era Enterprise cliffhanger without people expecting you to deliver the goods. The Enterprise was built a decade later, the Vulcan homeworld was destroyed, Chekovs birthday even slipped a few years. As a concept in big franchises, canon is more guidelines for the writers of future stories than for fans. The Prime Timeline Is Where All The Action Is Right Now. (I barely even want to mention the Spore Drive, as it's so canonically inconsistent.). Its a stretch though. DSC uses extensive holography aboard Federation starships. Abrams' Movies Were Made With No Star Trek TV Shows But Things Have Changed Marcus' search eventually led to the discovery of Botany Bay and a group of enhanced superhumans in cryogenic stasis. Nero's rage then focused on the first Federation vessel he found, the U.S.S. Farragut. Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Though many in the Federation opposed it, Picard spearheaded a massive evacuation effort to get as many people off Romulus as possible in the years before the supernova, only to have his rescue fleet destroyed by a surprise attack from a group of rogue synths. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. It's really the apprarance of the rest of the ships in the Kelvin timeline. Strange New Worlds Explores the Lingering Trauma of War With M'Benga. Keep this in mind because I will refer to it in a minute. However, back in what's known as the "Prime" timeline, Romulus remains destroyed. Discovery Officially Makes JJ Abrams' Star Trek Movies Canon - Screen Rant They didn't do that, instead leaning into the science fiction of it all. While Nero arrived in the Kelvin timeline in 2233, Spock didn't actually emerge from the black hole until 25 years later, and he found the vengeful Romulan waiting for him. The starships look similar, for example, but the designs are altered in many ways, and the same is true of things like phasers, communicators, and Starfleet uniforms. As I mentioned a moment ago, like Docs chalkboard drawing, both the Prime and Kelvin timelines coexist in the same universe, the latter a quantum reality existing alongside the former. For now, the three films released in the early 21st century are as Star Trek as it gets while remaining a little pocket universe for folks to enjoy on its own merits. Eventually he finds himself fighting alongside Starfleet (after a bit of fibbing) aboard the iconic USS Enterprise. The resulting confrontation led to Kelvin timeline Spock seeking the advice of Spock Prime, who recalled the deadly consequences of battling Khan. TOS did have Rec Rooms that were capable of holographic projections but these were more movie-like projections that simulations. As it stands now, the Prime Universe is still the one Star Trek fans need to care about the most. That means that, since the alternate reality doesn't really split until 2233, the loss of the Franklin is something we can consider to exist in both timelines. The Star Trek Kelvin Timeline Explained - Looper In the beginning, there was just Star Trek, now referred to as The Original Series (or TOS). Operating under the name John Harrison, Khanstaged successful attacks on Starfleet facilities that resulted in the death of Admiral Christopher Pike. Thats actually not as easy as you might think to answer, despite what the showrunners and cast might say. I previously worked on Kotaku, and the Official PlayStation Magazine and website. Directed by J.J. Abrams and starring Chris Pine, Zachary Quinto, and Zoe Saldana, Star Trek introduced the world to new versions of classic characters like Kirk, Spock, and Uhura, and it took us. Archer and his crew encountered the Xyrillians who used such devices in his era. Solidity has little to do with this. Kelvin, captained heroically to the very last minute by George Kirk, who lives just long enough to name his newborn son James. This officer revealed the major events of the Kelvin Timeline to the Starfleet of the Prime Universe. In this video, we try putting the new recent Constituion class mod against the JJ Enterprise. Enraged, a Romulan mining ship captain named Nero sought vengeance, and he attacked Spock's one-man vessel with his own ship, the Narada. This means that yes. I never really dig this deep in Trek and am unfamiliar what the common thought process is on this subject. That could be a reference to Archer and Enterprise. In "Despite Yourself" (Discovery, season 1, episode 10), Captain Lorca refers to data, recovered from the mirror universe rebel ship, that describes the Terran Empire's acquisition of the USS Defiant (NCC-1764). Well we have more modern looking Klingons, and the entire race seems to follow that look. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. There is a clear divide to when the Prime timeline stops, and where the Kelvin timeline begins. back then, the bridge looked much like a (for then) modern naval bridge. It . There is certainly a point in which the timelines diverged. The Konni is smaller and weaker than the DSC Conni, the Vengeance is nothing compared to the Prime S31 drone ships, the Konni is stuck with forward facing only weapons and got destroyed by drones, the DSC Conni has all sides covered and won against drones . Technically, even the Kelvin timeline Sarek is a character from the TOS universe, first appearing in the 1967 episode Journey to Babel. (More on this in a moment.). How do you ever have real stakes to your characters?" The look is part of the storytelling. During the chase, the two get caught in the gravitation pull of a black hole, which flings them back in time to the year 2233, over 150 years in the past. While were talking about time periods its worth mentioning just how cleverly the show is set to avoid specifically identifying a Prime or Kelvin timeline outright. In the Kelvin timeline, Pike meets Kirk in 2255, and you see a variety of Starfleet uniforms that look similar to the ones used three years later in 2258 (not counting the shipboard uniforms). That means we have an inciting incident for the Kelvin timeline that also exists as a major, galaxy-altering event in the Prime timeline, and that means there are consequences for both realities. When Picard debuted in 2020, one of the reasons he effectively retired from Starfleet was because of the destruction of Romulus. Kelvin. In Star Trek Beyond, the Enterprise crew discovers the buried U.S.S. Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, By the end of that season, an operative from the shady intelligence agency Section 31, played by David Cronenberg of all people, revealed that an alien Starfleet officer from the Kelvin Timeline crossed into their timeframe. Piece of evidence 3: the uniforms. Ambassador Spock attempted to use "red matter", a substance so powerful that a single drop can destroy a planet, to save Romulus by destroying the supernova. Star Trek Hints TNG Era Knows About Abrams' Kelvin Timeline Franklin, a Federation starship that was lost decades earlier, in an era before the Kelvin incident diverged the timelines. Mission: Terminal Expanse - Official Star Trek Online Wiki The Kelvin timeline, or "alternate universe Trek", creates a new environment in which the events of the more recent Star Trek films (Star Trek, Into Darkness, Beyond) won't contradict those. 6 Star Trek Kelvin Timeline Counterparts Does the US have a duty to negotiate the release of detained US citizens in the DPRK? Discovery makes that null and void, and at least 10 years earlier to boot. All rights reserved. Also please remember that ST:D is basically the only one except ST:Ent to mention the four founding races together, not to say anything about appearing "in person" (Tellerites, for example appear basically in TAS, ST:Ent and ST:D only, which is terrible performance), as well as that. In fact at least one major one. In the Kelvin timeline, they're still using the "old" system shown used on the Kelvin: the first four digits are the Gregorian year, so the ship was destroyed in 2233, Stardate 2233.04. It's the fact that you have holograms at all. First of all, I don't really give two craps what any of the writers or producers are saying about. For example, Beverly Crusher once spent an episode . Spock was able to stop the supernova's expansion but not before Romulus was destroyed, something he'd promised he could prevent. Everything that happens after that and therefore everything taking place in the show is part of the prime timeline, despite being kicked off by Event One. The film that would become 2009's Star Trek fell into the hands of screenwriters Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman, who decided to use time travel to create an alternate reality that would both raise the stakes for their "prequel" concept of a younger Kirk and Spock and also allow them to take some creative liberties with the well-worn characters. How do I figure out what size drill bit I need to hang some ceiling hooks? The Kelvin Timeline is Dead? Kurtzman Hints That There is No - NeoGAF I just ranted about producer statements. NY 10036. The uniform suggested they were from the mid-24th century, around the time of The Next Generation series. No holodecks. There were devices called protein resequencers that could make food, essentially organic 3D printers, but these were a world away from the teleporter tech apparently forming Burnhams clothes atom by atom. A canon-shaking Star Trek crossover may have just happened - Inverse That looks more like TOS dating (which was of course all over the place and not consistent), where the first one given in "Where No Man Has Gone Before" was 1312.4 (2265). Star Trek: How Picard Connects to Both the Prime and Kelvin Timelines - CBR - Aster Oct 5, 2017 at 2:28 2 There's a third option: It's post-Enterprise timeline. The Kelvin Timeline is a alternative quantum universe created when the Romulan Nero traveled to 2233 and destroyed the Federation starship U.S.S. Bare with me. Given that this would take place after Nero has entered this timeline, that would mean things are different to the point where the mod wore off faster. Out of universe - it's bloody hard to make things look as clunky as the original sets looked with modern materials. In 2009, Paramount Pictures released Star Trek, the first film in what would become a new action-oriented trilogy to reinvigorate the franchise at the worldwide box office. The attack by Nero that created these two divergent realities happened in 2233, the end of season 1 sees the Discovery make contact with the TOS-era Enterprise in 2257 when Commander Pike is still captain. Star Trek's Kelvin Timeline Was Inevitable (But Its Success Is Unique) Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more. This suggests that the Prime analog of the Kelvin would have been about the size of the Miranda-class, with a crew of around 100. And if you have a news tip, correction or comment, let us know at: community@space.com. With the help of some sci-fi stuff called "Red Matter," Spock and a giant Romulan mining vessel captained by Eric Bana's Nero traveled back in time. When . She loves all kinds of writing, from articles to stories to her debut novel, which she is seeking literary representation for. (I suspect director Frakes was making a Star Wars reference to go with Isaacs' imitation of other Star Trek actors.). Unbeknownst to Nero, when the Narada was drawn into the black hole, the Romulan ship was sent back to 2233, more than 150 years in the past. I find those statements highly questionable at best. How Star Trek Discovery fits into the Original Series' timeline In Star Trek: Beyond (2016), the Enterprise discovers the USS Franklin, a Federation ship that had been lost for decades. Early Tweets from Anthony Rapp, who plays astromycologist Lieutenant Paul Stamets in the show, seemed to clearly state Discovery is Prime timeline, Yes it is in the Prime timeline.
Preble High School Yearbook,
Nashville Pride Vendors,
What Is Auditor Negligence,
Articles K